STN-DBS versus GPi-DBS – Which DBS location is best?

STN-DBS versus GPI-DBS – Which DBS location is better?

Worldwide, the most common DBS location is a brain part called the Subthalamic Nucleus (STN-DBS). So, most doctors think it is better.

But in some patients, an alternative location may be better. This alternative location is the Globus Pallidus Interna (GPi). In fact, some doctors think that GPi-DBS is better in all cases!

Your doctor will do this thinking for you. He/She will tell you the proposed location.

But, its good to know how he/she thinks!

Let us learn quickly about the pros & cons of these locations.

What do you mean by DBS-Location?

DBS passes a small electrical current into a small brain part.

The small brain part is called the DBS location. Many doctors will call it the DBS Target instead.

Look at the picture below.

DBS Location or DBS Target
The end of the DBS wire marks the location. The DBS location will get a small current from the Battery. Usually, there are two wires, one on the left and one on the right.

See the wire going into the brain? The location where it ends is the location that will get the current. That is the “DBS location” (or “DBS Target”)

You could use any location in the brain. But doctors have found two great locations already.

The names of these two locations are:

  • Subthalamic Nucleus (STN)
  • Globus Pallidus Interna (GPi)

Subthalamic Nucleus (STN-DBS)

Where is the Subthalamic Nucleus (STN)?

The STN is deep, very deep, inside the brain.

There is one two STNs. One on the left, and one on the right.

They are also tiny. Like peas.

Ok, so close your eyes, and imagine. Two peas, almost touching each other, in the centre of your head, just below your ears.

SubthalamicNucleiPeas
The 2 STNs are like two small peas, in the center of the head.

That’s it! That is where the two STNs are.

What is the benefit of STN-DBS?

Let us say your doctor puts the end of the wire into the STN. And switches on the small current. What happens?

STN-DBS decreases the symptoms of Parkinson’s disease.

  • You need less levodopa after STN-DBS. Usually, the levodopa dose can be gradually reduced by 1/2.
  • STN-DBS also keeps acting throughout the day, so it decreases “Predictable-OFFs”.

A simple example:

Let us talk about an imaginary person – Mr. Salisbury.

Mr. Salisbury is already taking 12 tablets of levodopa. He takes 3 tablets every 4 hours.

A few minutes after he takes this high dose, he gets nauseous and sometimes starts shaking too much. But he insists “But I absolutely need this dose to function!

Stock e1599333110680
Mr. Salisbury needs a high dose of levodopa to function. But every dose makes him shake a lot. And every dose only works for 2 hours.

“I know these are Dyskinesias” he says. “But I put up with them because I need that high dose of levodopa to function!“.

That is not all. Just 2 hours after taking the levodopa, it’s effect wears off. Mr. Salisbury goes into the OFF-state again. He almost completely freezes. This wearing-Off is very predictable.

After STN-DBS, Mr. Salisbury becomes ON with only 1.5 tablets of Levodopa. Not only that, the effect now lasts for 4 hours.

Even when he goes into the OFF-state, he is not completely OFF. He does not completely freeze.

Mr. Salisbury is particularly happy that his levodopa dose has decreased. Because his dose has decreased, he has less severe dyskinesias.

fresh 1239267 1920
After STN-DBS, you may need only 50% of your current levodopa dose.

In summary:

STN-DBS decreases both Predictable-OFF & Dyskinesias.

But, the effect on dyskinesias is indirect.

What are the side-effects of STN-DBS?

STN-DBS causes two characteristic side-effects.

  • Increasing severe depression, if you already have it.
  • Increasing memory problems, if you already have them.
DepressionParkinsons
If you are dramatically depressed or have severe memory problems, perhaps STN would not be the right DBS location for you.

STN-DBS may rarely cause depression or memory problems. But this is rare. Mostly, all it does is to increase severe problems, if you already have them.

So, if you already have these very severe problems, STN-DBS may not be the right choice.

What can you choose instead of the usual STN-DBS?

If you have these problems, and they are severe, you should probably not choose usual DBS.

You can choose:

  • Not to have DBS or
  • STN-DBS of only one side or
  • DBS of another target called the Globus Pallidus Interna (GPi)

If depression or memory problems are extremely dramatic, then not having DBS may be considered.

For borderline problems, many doctors consider another target – the GPi. This is called GPi-DBS.


Globus Pallidus Interna (GPi-DBS)

Where is the Globus Pallidus Interna (GPi)?

The GPi is not as deeply located as the STN.

There are two GPis. One on the left, and one on the right.

The GPis are bigger. They are shaped like this yo-yo here.

Imagine a small yo-yo like this, inside your head, just above your ears.

GpiYoYo
The two GPi look somewhat like a Yo-Yo. They are larger than the STN.

That’s it! That’s where the two GPi are.

What is the benefit of GPi-DBS?

Overall, GPi-DBS causes the same benefits as STN-DBS. But, the way it does so is different.

GPi-DBS decreases the side-effects of levodopa, especially DYSKINESIA.

Let’s consider an imaginary person, Ms. Mary.

Ms. Mary is not able to take enough levodopa to decrease his symptoms. She can only take 4 tablets in a day.

Why? Because when she takes more tablets, the body starts shaking too much. Like the video below, posted by a brave patient on youtube. These movements are called “Dyskinesia”.

I really wish I could take more medication!” says Mary. “But if I try to increase it, this dyskinesia just becomes intolerable!”

Wouldn’t it be wonderful if these bad movements went away? GPi-DBS does that.

After GPi-DBS, Ms. Mary can take 8 tablets per day without any side-effects. Her Parkinson’s symptoms are much better.

After levodopa is increased, will GPi-DBS benefit Mary as much as STN-DBS would have?

Yes. The latest research indicates that the improvement in movements is similar.

In summary:

GPi-DBS decreases Dyskinesias. It enables you to take enough levodopa. The net improvement is similar to STN-DBS.

So, both lead to the same amount of improvement… what is the fuss about?

Well, you see, GPi-DBS may have fewer side-effects.

The Sub-thalamic nucleus (STN) is part of a system that controls emotions and memory. This system is called the limbic system. So, both emotions & memory suffer when DBS overloads the STN.

The GPi isn’t intimately connected to emotions or memory. Therefore, DBS of the GPi has a lesser chance of producing these side-effects.

Does GPi-DBS have any disadvantages?

Not many.

Some doctors believe that GPi-DBS is ever so slightly less effective. But, other studies show no difference. Overall, its safe to say that there is no dramatic difference in improvement between STN-DBS & GPi-DBS.

Untitled 3
The improvement in movement after STN-DBS and after GPi-DBS is similar.

The GPi is slightly larger than the STN. So, it requires a somewhat higher current. This can make the DBS battery run out sooner.

Let us quickly summarize. GPi-DBS:

  • Produces almost the same improvement in movement as STN-DBS
  • Decreases Dyskinesias
  • Is less likely to worsen depression
  • Is less likely to worsen memory problems.
  • May need more frequent battery replacement.

STN-DBS versus GPi-DBS

When is GPi-DBS better than STN-DBS?

The answer to this question will seem very simple now.

GPi-DBS may be better than STN-DBS when:
1. Your main problem is severe uncontrollable dyskinesias, because of which you are on minuscule doses of Levodopa

2. You are significantly depressed.

3. You have significant problems with thinking & memory

Should GPi-DBS be done in all cases, instead of STN-DBS?

Ah! My friend… so some people have raised the next question.

If GPi DBS is equally effective and has fewer side-effects, why not do it in all cases?

Some authorities have indeed suggested that it should replace STN-DBS as the DBS location of choice.

The answer lies in two words: Customized Care.

  1. Suppose you have a patient who is taking 12 tablets of levodopa daily. He still has marked Predictable-OFF and moderate dyskinesia. What would be a good target? STN
  2. Suppose you have a patient, who is mildly depressed. She is taking only 3 tablets per day but still has severe dyskinesias. What would be a good target? GPi
  3. Suppose you have a patient who really, really wants to decrease his levodopa intake, because it is causing severe uncontrollable nausea. What is a good target? STN

And so on…

There are many Antibiotics, because there is a time and place for each one.

There are two DBS targets, because there is a time and place for each one.

Each one of us is unique. We need treatments selected for our uniqueness.

poppy 1819645 1920
Each one of us is unique. And so are our problems.

Further reading / References:

Here are some resources if you want to read further. They may be too technical though.

  1. Here is a good scientific article on this topic, if you want to read it: [Ramirez-Zamora et al 2018 – JAMA Neurology]. You may need University Access to get the full text.
  2. Here is a freely accessible article. It describes the thought process as it relates to a single patient. [Patel et al 2017 – Tremor & other hyperkinetic movements]

I know that this information can be overwhelming.

As for all these articles on DBS, I would like to end my article with the picture below. Have a long talk with your doctor. He/She will help you make the right choice.

Doctor talking to patient about DBS for Parkinson's
Talk to your doctor in detail about your evaluation results, expectations and fears before getting DBS surgery. Image from: freepik.com
Caution: This information is not a substitute for professional care. Do not change your medications/treatment without your doctor's permission.
Dr. Siddharth Kharkar

Dr. Siddharth Kharkar

Dr. Siddharth Kharkar has been recognized as one of the best neurologists in Mumbai by Outlook India magazine and India today Magazine. He is a board certified (American Board of Psychiatry & Neurology certified) Neurologist.

Dr. Siddharth Kharkar is a Epilepsy specialist in Mumbai & Parkinson's specialist in Mumbai, Maharashtra, India.

He has trained in the best institutions in India, US and UK including KEM hospital in Mumbai, Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, University of California at San Francisco (UCSF), USA & Kings College in London.

Call 022-4897-1800

Send Message


NeuroPlus Epilepsy & Parkinson's Clinic - Dr. Kharkar IconNeuroPlus Epilepsy & Parkinson's Clinic - Dr. Kharkar

near LIC, Dr Balabhai Nanavati hospital, near LIC, Swami Vivekananda Road, LIC Colony, Vile Parle

4.6 87 reviews

  • Avatar Paras Prabhu ★★★★★ 6 months ago
    Out patient is epileptic from about 10 years and her seizure gotten worse during the past year with the frequency of about 3-4 times a week.So we consulted … More Dr. Kharkar. He tried a few medicines, and within 1.5-2 months now the patient is feeling very well now. There are no seizures for 14 days currently.Dr. tried to keep medicines as minimum as possible. He also tried to keep the cost of the treatment minimum.When some of the medicines started showing side-effects, he was quick to switch the medicines to the better options.Overall I think we are getting a best of the available treatments. We thank you very much Dr. Kharkar.
  • Avatar Dr Shobha Sankhe ★★★★★ a month ago
    Dr Kharkar is gem of a doctor with tremendous patience, empathy, genuine concern for his patients .He guides them very methodically & scientifically … More for their neurological ill healthOur epilepsy patient is extremely happy with his treatment , Patient feels better by just visiting him too!May his selfless service to humanity flourish to reach all the needy patients!!
  • Avatar shrruti khanna ★★★★★ a month ago
    I consulted Dr Sidharth for my sister who has become very hyper and aggressive and we could not understand the issue. Keeping in mind she is someone with … More special needs Dr Sidharth was extremely understanding of the situation and did not put her through unnecessary investigation and avoided a very long stay at the hospital. He was infact more keen on her returning home to her natural environment. We highly appreciate Dr Sidharth for his effort and for looking into the matter with utmost care. It was a very difficult decision for my family to get my sister admitted but we are glad we did it under his care.Thankyou Doc.
  • Avatar Prashant Purohit ★★★★★ a month ago
    my name is prashant purohit. I m become completely bed ridden from last 9 months and was unable to walk. I couldnt find out the cause even after visiting … More many doctors and many hospital in Ahmedabad nd jodhpur.started losing hope. A good friend of mine suggested to visit a neurologist. After searching a lot, I came to know about Dr. Siddharth Kharkar and took his appointment in Nanavati Hospital. He examined and said that he suffered from \u201cPKD(PAROXYSMAL KNESIGENIC DYSKNESIA\u201c. He assured us to reverse this in 5 days time. And indeed this happened. I started recovering miraculously. today I am fully well fit I m walking as normal . Many Many thanks to Dr. Siddharth Kharkhar sir for giving me a new life.
  • Avatar Sanjay Pradhan ★★★★★ 7 months ago
    Dr. Kharkar is truly exceptional. He is extremely knowledgeable. But simultaneously, he is extremely patient and kind - taking the time and care to respond … More to all the questions. It is rare to come across a doctor who is not in a hurry to get on to the next patient, but instead, focuses on the one in front with full attention, expertise and compassion. A great experience.
  • Avatar N N ★★★★★ a year ago
    We visited Dr. Kharkhar for treatment regarding my mum - who is a multi-stroke patient and has aphasia. Certain medications were creating complications … More with her condition and Dr. Kharkhar was able to help mitigate the issue. We found him and his approach to be incredibly compassionate, considerate, individualized and patient-friendly. He advice is astute, up-to-date and empathetic. His treatment always comes from a deeply human place and is about seeing how to help the patient and their caregivers feel more at ease. Something that is quite rare and refreshing within the medical community.We feel that he genuinely cares about the patients that he is treating and is always kind and respectful in his communication. Moreover, his admin team is very efficient and prompt and it's a pleasure to deal with them.Would highly recommend Dr Kharkhar himself - though we must say our experience with Nanavati hospital itself has been less than ideal.Hope this helps.
  • Avatar Manish Ranjan ★★★★★ a year ago
    I have been visiting Dr Kharkar for treatment of my father. He is a very friendly doctor. He listens to our concerns with lot of patience. He also explains … More the issue in much greater details. He has really been of great help. My father is much better now.
  • Avatar Pinakin Shah ★★★★★ a year ago
    One of the best Dr. Gives complete attention and time to listen to patient's history, issues. Explains various options of treatment with pros and … More cons.
  • Avatar Lawrence Castellino ★★★★★ a year ago
    Exceptional experience with an expert,Dr. Kharkar is a knowledge house. It is rare nowadays to find doctors with patience, knowledge, and a flair for … More handling patient’s questions, besides Dr. Kharkar’s bedside manners are exemplary. I am privileged to be treated by such an amazing soul. I have told him and will repeat it here that “I am advancing my move back to India although I am a US Citizen, because I know I am in good hands and will be well taken care of. Thanks Dr. Kharkar for your selfless service!
  • Avatar Hemant Kansara ★★★★★ a year ago
    Great doctor!! Really appreciate.The doctor diagnosed to my sister correctly and start treatment, she has good improvement after taking medicine prescribed … More by doctor as no epilepsy attake. We have good experience with the doctor. Thank you

1 thought on “STN-DBS versus GPi-DBS – Which DBS location is best?”

  1. Great article! Thanks for sharing. We will be returning not long from now.

    Reply

Leave a Comment

Noted as one of the best Neurologists in Mumbai

India Today Magazine - 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023

Outlook India Magazine - 2021, 2023

Ex-Assistant Professor, University of Alabama, USA

Outlook India - Best neurologist in Mumbai